Yes, very cautiously. Actually, reading that I've found myself to be so anti-hyped about it that I was pleasantly surprised to hear that it has some good bits. I'd like them to pull it off.
PC Gamer ripped into it a little a couple of issues back, saying that they were worried it was losing the whole open endedness. But the devs responded by bringing the reporter back in and showing him some more of the game, and actually, its still pretty open ended. The second report from them was hugely more optimistic.
I could only read the first page as I found myself getting excited again and I don't want to get my hopes up too high. Also it sounds like it might be the first game I want to play only after the first patch comes out.