Page 4 of 5

Posted: July 2nd, 2008, 0:40
by Fear
Spoiler:
ZOMG I let Ashley die saving the nuke... no humping for me :(

Posted: July 2nd, 2008, 3:02
by deject
Sheriff Fatman wrote:I'm a big fan of KoToR, and Baldur's Gate, but this game is just hard work. The map and inventory are rubbish. There is far too much pissing around in the inventory to get to where you want to be and the map has been utterly useless, so far.

Meh, as I said: PC snob.
OK, see, you fail hard for sure now. KOTOR was a much worse console port in every way than Mass Effect is. It had the shitty textures that shouted "HEY I WAS MADE FOR THE ORIGINAL XBOX." The inventory and equipment screens are almost exactly the same. Selecting skills was a much bigger pain in the ass in KotOR, what with needing to scroll through 3 items to get what you want, and that's after you've properly got the mouse on the right stupid small box. I just don't get how you think it's a shitty console port. The only port that behaves this well in recent memory is COD 4, which was more simultaneously developed than a port. Bioshock wasn't this good.

Posted: July 2nd, 2008, 7:34
by Dog Pants
I've got to say I really can't see your point either. The inventory system is annoying, but not nearly enough to spoil the game. I can't remember a lot about Baldur's Gate other than that I was completely uninspired by it and gave up half way through because it just felt lika a grind. Mass Effect's quests all feel like a natural progression, and the dialogue gives them more gravity than the typical 'clear my cellar of rats' quests most RPGs lump you with.

Posted: July 2nd, 2008, 8:17
by FatherJack
Sheriff Fatman wrote:It's a console port. From the first moment I started the game it was glaringly obvious. I'll hold my hands up as a PC snob, but the entire interface, quest system, map and anything else was shit; it's cluncky, counter-intuitive and far too much like hard work.
I just got bored.
You should have seen it when it was a console game. The weapon selection is massively improved for the PC, the Mako is (a bit) more drivable and the hacking bits are..well I can actually do them on the PC.

Yeah, it's a console port, but a much better one than a lot around, they've made an effort to improve things and make them more PC-friendly, far more so than they did with the KoTORs and Jade Empire and don't even get me started on those "Games for Windows" abominations where you have to click the buttons of a rendering of the 360 controller to operate them.

It does get a bit samey, particularly if you do all the missions where it plonks the Mako on a planet, and since I've taken the same approach I did in Bioshock of hacking everything I see - that can get a bit monotonous.

How does it work if you have no hacking skills yourself, do you have to use mongy-gel every time?

Posted: July 2nd, 2008, 8:21
by Dog Pants
FatherJack wrote:How does it work if you have no hacking skills yourself, do you have to use mongy-gel every time?
You use the skill of your comrades, which is why I always take Tali on landings. From what I've encountered, if you don't have enough skill you just can't do it, omni-gel or otherwise.

Posted: July 2nd, 2008, 10:07
by spoodie
Well I liked the original, console version and I'm not going to play it on the PC as I've already finished it on the 360.

Posted: July 2nd, 2008, 15:01
by deject
After I got about halfway through the game I had so much mongni-gel that I just did that anyways even though I could easily beat the hacking mini-game, mostly because I was trying to get through the cookie cutter side quests as fast as possible.

Posted: July 2nd, 2008, 21:07
by Sheriff Fatman
Well, it seems I am in the minority here :)

I've put a few more hours into it today and nothing I have seen has changed my mind. I'm not saying it's a bad port, but it is still a console game nonetheless: I don't like the interface and it seems to be a struggle to do anything. Perhaps I am too used to being spoon-fed "go here and do this" quests from PC-centric games, but the quest system is a pain in the arse. I'm constantly having to click backwards and forwards between the myriad of entries I have in my log to work out where the fuck I need to be (which more often than not is in another galaxy).

As I said, it's just too much hard work, and it's boring.

Posted: July 2nd, 2008, 21:29
by spoodie
Sheriff Fatman wrote:Well, it seems I am in the minority here :)
Yes, get to the back of the bus.

Posted: July 2nd, 2008, 21:29
by Dog Pants
Ah, I think I understand what you mean there. You can't access the journal from the navigation screen, so you need to come out and check, then try to remember the name of the planet and system you're after. I did get briefly and slightly annoyed by that.

Had I not already known though, I'd have never guessed it was a console port. Feels fine to me. You must be more sensitive :P

Posted: July 2nd, 2008, 21:35
by Shada
Sheriff Fatman wrote:Perhaps I am too used to being spoon-fed "go here and do this" quests from PC-centric games
So now you're picking out GOOD traditional PC game features like reduced hand-holding and an encouragement to figure things out yourself and saying it's the mark of a console port? :D

Anyway, by clicking back and forth through log entries, do you mean the journal? The ones that clearly say "Go to this system in this sector and do this"? Because I don't see how you're having trouble working it out.

Posted: July 2nd, 2008, 21:35
by Roman Totale
spoodie wrote: Yes, get to the back of the bus.
The short bus.

Posted: July 2nd, 2008, 21:44
by Dog Pants
Roman Totale wrote:
The short bus.
The other bus.

Posted: July 2nd, 2008, 23:52
by Killavodka
Dog Pants wrote:
The other bus.
The Rhom bus

Posted: July 3rd, 2008, 18:01
by HereComesPete
Killavodka wrote:
The Rhom bus
:facepalm: :spang:

Posted: July 4th, 2008, 7:22
by Anery
So far I have
1. Shot everybody I get the chance to
2. Pissed the council off somewhat by blatantly ignoring them
3. Biffed an alien

The alien was the most fun

Posted: July 4th, 2008, 9:05
by Dog Pants
Crikey, you're flying through. I only did the romantic bit last night, same night I finished the game.

I'm really rather impressed, very well put together and a nice (relatively) original story. Nice to play a character who doesn't have amnesia.

I'll definately be playing through again, if only to try the other romantic sub-plots and try life as a renegade (and this time maybe not let the Council get blown up :))

Posted: July 4th, 2008, 11:47
by Lateralus
Well I just found that one of my mates has the xbox version of this, so given that it comes for the bargain price of Free, I might give it a go.

Posted: July 29th, 2008, 16:51
by Sheriff Fatman

Posted: July 29th, 2008, 17:13
by Dog Pants
Is it any good? I heard it put a time limit on the game.